Morality of the Green Belt

Back to News, Events and Blog

Morality of the Green Belt

An interesting discussion on Radio 4’s Moral Maze on the Green Belt and home ownership in this country.  

Click here to hear more:  Moral Maze

When it comes to talking about home ownership in this country it quickly divides in to the “have’s” and “have not’s.” According to the OECD fewer than half of low to middle income families are now able to afford to buy a house and some campaigners estimate that, by 2020, families earning the National Living Wage would be unable to afford to buy homes in 98 per cent of the country. The answer, according to many, is radical deregulation of the planning laws and building on the greenbelt. 8 million new family homes could be built if just 2% of the greenbelt was handed over to developers. To those threatened with the prospect of bulldozers arriving in a field near their home, it will mean urban sprawl and the destruction of large swathes of natural countryside so that builders can make a quick profit.

Economists argue that when the greenbelt was created in 1955 it arbitrarily distorted the market for building land. But the current housing crisis is about moral issues too and in such a polarising debate it’s vital that we’re able to identify them to get the root of the issue. How do we draw the line between legitimate self-interest and Luddite nimbyism? People talk a lot about inter-generational justice, but do we have an absolute moral duty to provide for the next generation whatever the cost? How do we choose between conflicting moral goods? We all love a beautiful pastoral scene, but does the physical landscape have a moral value beyond how it can be used in the service of mankind? Obviously, having somewhere to live is a fundamental need, but is home ownership a moral good and even a human right? Panellists George Buskell, Poppy Cleary, Maddie Groeger-Wilson and Jane Fidge.

Share this

Latest Articles

Congratulations to Stadhampton

By cfo-admin | 26 Apr' 17

Congratulations to Stadhampton who have recently published their Community Led Plan.  Further details can be found under our ... Read more

Northmoor Village Hall Trade Soiree

By cfo-admin | 25 Apr' 17

Northmoor Village Hall are holding a trade showcase soiree on Thursday 11th May 4:00pm – 6.30pm.    It will be an opp ... Read more

Abingdon -on-Thames Town Council supports a Community Led plan

By cfo-admin | 21 Apr' 17

People living in and around Abingdon-on-Thames are being urged to help forge its future. Everyone in the area is invited to g ... Read more

View our Facebook page View our Twitter page